Separation Pay Recoupment
Separation pay recoupment is a process in which the federal government withholds a portion or all monthly disability compensation or retired pay to recover benefits paid when the service member left military service. The financial consequences of separation pay recoupment can be brutal.
Certain separation benefits paid by the Department of Defense can later be recovered through VA disability compensation. VA's transition-benefits guide warns service members that if they received separation pay and later receive disability compensation, monthly VA compensation may be withheld until the required amount has been recouped. VA also specifically lists separation pay and disability severance pay among the things that can reduce disability compensation. In other words, the government generally does not treat these payments as two completely independent pots of money.
The existence of this law is not the most troubling part. The surprise is: The separation money you are receiving today could affect VA disability compensation in the future. This consequence is usually not meaningfully explained to veterans. A veteran might build a civilian life believing the transaction was finished, only to have the issue surface years or decades later. This is something every separating service member receiving one of these payments should understand before signing the paperwork.
Not every separation-related payment is identical. There are different programs and different rules involving separation pay, special separation benefits and disability severance pay. For example, VA guidance explains that disability severance pay is generally recouped from compensation associated with the same disability for which the severance was paid.
There are also important exceptions. Certain veterans who received disability severance pay for combat-related injuries and separated on or after January 28, 2008, may be exempt from recoupment. Do not assume that because a letter says the VA intends to withhold money, every number in that letter is automatically correct. Find out exactly what you received. Find the original separation paperwork. Check the gross payment. Check what was withheld for taxes. Determine what type of separation or severance benefit it actually was. Then compare that information with what VA says it intends to recover.
Another detail that can involve thousands of dollars is that, for applicable separation payments made after September 30, 1996, recoupment is generally based on the after-tax amount, rather than simply taking the original gross separation figure and demanding the entire amount. Do not rely on memory if the payment occurred 15 or 20 years ago. Pull the documentation. A mistake involving tens of thousands of dollars can alter your family's finances for years.
What To Do If a Recoupment Notice is Received
Do not ignore it. Do not immediately assume that nothing can be questioned simply because the letter came from the VA. Verify the type of payment you received, the original amount, applicable tax withholding, the amount VA proposes to recoup and whether any exception applies to your circumstances. Then get qualified help.
An accredited Veterans Service Organization representative can help review the paperwork and determine whether VA is applying the rules correctly. If the withholding would create severe financial hardship, ask specifically whether the rate of recoupment can be adjusted. Veterans experiencing extreme financial hardship may request an adjusted repayment schedule, although recoupment itself is legally different from an ordinary VA debt and the VA isn't necessarily authorized to simply erase the statutory requirement. That is an important distinction.
Until the system becomes clearer, veterans have to protect themselves. Keep your separation records. Know exactly what kind of payment you received. Understand the recoupment rules. Check the VA's math. And get an accredited representative involved when something doesn't look right. The worst time to learn how separation pay affects VA disability compensation is when you're waiting for a disability check that is not coming.
Read the full article here.
